Nike Downshifter 12 review

7 expert score
0 user's score
As editorial policy, we do not accept free samples. We purchased this pair at Running Warehouse with our own money.
Review written on 29th October by Kristin Lassen Experienced Runner and Stability Shoe Expert
75 other reviews

Nike Downshifter 12 Verdict

The Nike Downshifter 12 is a supportive, stable-feeling running shoe that is an excellent buy for the price. Comfortable for walking and general wear, the ride can feel blocky when picking up the pace, yet the full-coverage outsole provides grip and durability long term.

The pros

  • Stable ride
  • Durable build quality
  • Full coverage, protective, grippy outsole
  • Available in wide fit
  • Affordable price

The cons

  • Small toe box
  • Blocky ride
  • Discouraging toe-off

Where to buy

Best offers today in United States, all prices in USD

Rating breakdown

Comfort
8.0
Build quality
9.0
Upper
6.0
Sole unit
7.0
Landing
8.0
Transition
7.0
Toe-off
5.0
Traction
10
Durability
9.0
Value / Price
10

Facts / Specs

Brand
Model
Downshifter 12
Previous model
Weight
10 oz (283 g)
MSRP
$70.00

Heel
mm.
Toe
mm.
Heel drop
10 mm.
Carbon plate
No plate

Size/Fit

Sizing
Buy half size bigger
Heel fit
Normal
Midfoot fit
Normal
Toebox fit
Tight

Cushioning & ride

Type of cushioning
Balanced
Amount of cushioning
Medium cushioning
Stability
Very stable
Flexibility
Medium

Usage

Racing
Speedwork
Daily training  
Long distance racing
Ultra distance racing

Who should buy the Nike Downshifter 12 ?

Downshifter is best suited for walkers who want to mix in some running; wide and extra-wide versions makes this med-narrow shoe an option for most walkers and beginning runners. The durable sole unit with ribbed heel coverage curling up the back resists wear for heel strikers and those with uneven gait patterns.

Who should not buy the Nike Downshifter 12 ?

This is not the shoe for runners regularly going over four miles or speed-focused runs.

Nike Downshifter 12 Introduction

Picture of Nike Downshifter 12

Downshifter is Nike’s budget running shoe—it really is a steal for only $70 USD, up $10 from the 11.

The shoe has been completely redone. A new upper design drops the overlays for more breathability but still runs approximately one-inch wide support stripes inside the upper from the middle shoe laces diagonally down to the early heel on both sides.

Stubborn rubber patches that run the length of the outsole are deeply treaded (for a road shoe) and give no allusion to its lower cost.

(The similar shoe ASICS Gel-Excite is my next review—coming soon! )

This morning I ran 6 miles with the Downshifter on one foot and Gel-Excite on the other, switching which was which halfway through. I found that Downshifter offers a more secure fit and feels more stable underfoot while Gel-Excite ($15 more), has a smoother transition and rolls off the toes, as well as more room in the toe box.

Compared with adidas Duramo, Downshifter brings a more snug fit and similar midsole cushion; Duramo’s regular width allows for med-wide feet to be more comfortable without ordering wide/extra wide as may be needed with Downshifter.

Other similar shoes include Nike Revolution, adidas RunFalcon, Nike Winflo, and Saucony Cohesion.

Nike Downshifter 12 First Impressions

Picture of Nike Downshifter 12

Unboxing for the first time, this shoe’s simple design and my particular colorway left me unimpressed. The design grew on me in upcoming weeks as it looked sharp when worn as a crossover shoe for running, other workouts, and casual wear.

I surprised myself by how often I chose this shoe to go with an outfit for everyday use. Looking at pictures of the 11 I do prefer this updated, simple design.

The first wear felt constrictive with a medium-narrow fit and definite “block” vibe, but the stable base was also strangely appealing.

The narrow toebox with narrow-medium heel into midfoot will require many to size up a half size.

Nike Downshifter 12 Upper

Picture of Nike Downshifter 12

Downshifter’s structured mesh is reinforced by an internal layer from a fully gusseted (attached to the base all around) tongue; together they allow for medium breathability. I expected it to be a hot shoe, especially with the added factor of a smaller toe box, but it was never uncomfortably warm (running inside and in average fall temps).

The generously-padded tongue is wide and protective, adding a layer to the upper all around as it attaches down to the midsole. This tongue and full gusset add to the closed-in feeling of the narrow toe.

Picture of Nike Downshifter 12

Running in Downshifter and Excite back to back, a bit more freedom for the toes in Excite was really refreshing. The toebox itself looks about the same as that of GEL-Excite, but the difference in feel is due to this tongue layer. Nike has a great design going but could increase comfort by adding (at least) a couple millimeters of room to make up for the internal layers.

The feel from the medium-width laces is just how it should be. Laces run through the tongue for added security.

Low-average padding hugs the ankle above a decent heel counter. Downshifter’s heel counter is thicker and provides more heel support than the heel counter in Gel-Excite or (especially) Duramo.

Picture of Nike Downshifter 12

The large loop off the heel is perfectly sized for ease of use, but with this shoe I did not need help pulling it on.

A different-colored (orange in my shoe) densely-knit strip runs from the middle laces back to the heel on each side to provide more support than a simple layer of mesh; it peeks through a visibility window.
The tip of the toe box is also reinforced with an extra densely-knit layer for durability, which has the softer “tongue” material extended down between the toes and outer mesh as well.

Like Duramo, the sock liner is attached to the base. Pulling it up, it is decently thick (half mm.) which is more than most sock liners.

Attractive colorways span neutral shades with a few pops of color along with brighter options.
This shoe is made from 20% recycled content.

Nike Downshifter 12 Sole Unit

Picture of Nike Downshifter 12

The foam midsole in Downshifter is not given fancy branding, or even a description online. The softness is similar to On’s Helion foam and the Lightmotion foam in adidas Duramo.

This midsole is slightly more firm than adidas Lightstrike, ASICS FF Blast, and HOKA’s CMEVA foams but is softer than ASICS (basic) Flytefoam.

The outsole tread covers the full base besides a curved guidance line which minimizes horizontal force transfer, a flex line below the heel patch, and small windows that reveal the midsole. The rubber has average to high durability, with a light wear pattern showing after 50 running miles (plus much walking—pictures with the review show approx. 50 miles). Rungs going up the heel provide grip and durability for a heel strike.

This is a supportive shoe that bends at the ball but keeps a stiff midfoot and has a 10 mm. drop in height from the heel down to the forefoot.

The shoe provides a medium-soft landing that goes into a so-so transition and ends with a noticeable toe-off (the best disappear into the air without a thought).

Nike Downshifter 12 Conclusions

Picture of Nike Downshifter 12

Nike put a lot of material into Downshifter 12 for its low cost. The shoe is impressively cushioned and secure-feeling. The ride is supported and stable, but a boxy transition and toe-off are what bring my rating down for running in this shoe.

It just doesn’t encourage the motion. Wear it for walking and casual wear with the occasional run, and you’ll get a great shoe that will last a long time.

Remember to size up a half size if you are between sizes or do not want a snug toe.

How does the Downshifter 12 compare?

Nike Winflo 10
Nike Downshifter 12
Adidas Duramo 10
Expert score
10
7
8
User score
Best price
Retail price
US$99.99
US$70
US$70
Brand
Weight
9.9 oz
10 oz
9 oz
Heel Drop
10 mm
10 mm
9 mm
Recommended for
Daily training
Daily training
Daily training
Cushioning type
balanced
balanced
responsive
Cushioning amount
Medium cushioning
Medium cushioning
Medium cushioning
Flexibility
flexible
medium
flexible
Stability
very stable
very stable
some stability
Sizing
true to size
buy half size bigger
true to size

Why you can trust us

As editorial policy, we do not accept free samples from companies.
We purchased this pair of Nike at Running Warehouse  with our own money.

This page contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Read more about our policy.
Lowest price:

$70

Nike Downshifter 12 price comparison

Best offers today in United States, all prices in USD

Reviewed by Kristin

This review was written by Kristin Lassen on 29th October.
Running long for over twenty years, Kristin has found peace and solidarity with like-minded 'soles,' cheetahs of all speeds and walks of life. Kristin holds a bachelor's degree in exercise science and an MA in theology; running is where her dual passions for truth and fitness merge. She teaches college classes and together with her husband raises four children, corn, and soybeans in rural Iowa.

User feedback (0)

Lowest price:
$70

Where to buy

Best offers today in United States, all prices in USD

Similar shoes to Nike Downshifter 12

Nike Winflo 11 Review

The Nike Winflo 11 is a shoe for anyone! It’s such a versatile shoe and ... (Read expert review)

Nike Alphafly 3 Review

The Nike Alphafly 3 is a superb top-tier racer and the best Alphafly version ... (Read expert review)

Nike Revolution 7 Review

The Nike Revolution 7 is a budget friendly shoe with a comfortable fit and ... (Read expert review)