Comparison: Brooks Glycerin 23 vs ASICS Nimbus 28

The Glycerin and the Nimbus are two very popular max-cushioned trainers that have been around for a long time. Here we compare these two max-cushioned trainers.

Lateral view of the Brooks Glycerin 23Glycerin 23
Picture of ASICS Gel Nimbus 28Gel Nimbus 28

Written by
Marathon Runner and Shoe Expert · 222 articles

Published

We buy every shoe we test with our own money No free samples How we review

The Glycerin is a premium max-cushioned trainer from Brooks. It's a more premium version of the Brooks Ghost. It was the softest, plushest Brooks trainer for a long time but now there's a softer, Max version of it. The Glycerin is on its 23rd iteration. It costs $175.

The Nimbus is a premium, max-cushioned trainer from ASICS and is currently the softest, plushest ASICS trainer on the market. It's on its 28th version so it has been around for longer than the Glycerin. The Nimbus costs $170.

This article will tell you which of these max-cushioned trainers is better for you.

Similarity and differences: Glycerin 23 vs Gel Nimbus 28

Our verdict: Both shoes are premium, maximum-cushion trainers. The Glycerin is the stable, fast (but slightly less soft) shoe while the Nimbus is all about plush cushioning and comfort for slower, longer runs.

Brooks Glycerin 23Brooks Glycerin 23Asics Gel Nimbus 28Asics Gel Nimbus 28
Expert score7/107/10
User scoreNo ratings yetNo ratings yet
Best price, menBrooks Glycerin 23, men: from $136.36 list price $174.95 22% off as of 16 Nov, 02:47 UTC at Amazon See deal Asics Gel Nimbus 28, men: from $124.95 list price $169.95 26% off as of 16 Nov, 02:22 UTC at Amazon See deal
Best price, womenBrooks Glycerin 23, women: from $125.25 list price $174.95 28% off as of 15 Nov, 20:12 UTC at Amazon See dealAsics Gel Nimbus 28, women: from $124.95 list price $169.95 26% off as of 16 Nov, 02:02 UTC at Amazon See deal
Buy ifyou want a comfortable, cushioned shoe you can take on faster/shorter runs.you want a soft ride for recovery or slow runs - or simply want an extremely comfortable, plus running experience.
ReviewGlycerin 23 reviewGel Nimbus 28 review
Brand
Shoe type
Weight10.9 oz9.6 oz lighter
Heel drop8 mm8 mm
CushioningMedium cushioningHighly cushioned
Cushioning typeBalancedBalanced/plush
StabilityVery stableSome stability
FlexibilityFlexibleMedium
Sizingtrue to sizetrue to size
Best forDaily trainingDaily training, long distance racing
Retail priceUS$174.95US$169.95

Score breakdown: Glycerin 23 vs Gel Nimbus 28

Glycerin 23Gel Nimbus 28
9Comfort9
7Sole unit7
8Upper8
7Transition7
7Toe-off7
9Durability8

Glycerin 23 wins: Durability

Gel Nimbus 28 wins: lighter

Even: Comfort, Sole unit, Upper, Transition, Toe-off

Sole unit: Glycerin 23 vs Gel Nimbus 28

Lateral midsole of the Brooks Glycerin 23 showing the stack heightGlycerin 23
Picture of ASICS Gel Nimbus 28Gel Nimbus 28

The midsole of the Glycerin is made of DNA Tuned, a supercritical EVA. It’s dual density which means that it’s softer in the rearfoot and firmer in the forefoot. The firmer forefoot is designed to make it feel faster.

The Glycerin has a very balanced ride which is neither too firm nor too soft. The ride feels more like a versatile daily trainer than a max-cushioned trainer for only slow runs.

The Nimbus midsole is made of FF Blast+, which is an EVA blend foam. It’s a single density midsole but it does have a hidden gel unit situated in its rearfoot.

The Nimbus has a very soft ride. The midsole compresses a lot and your feet sink down into the soft foam. It has a super plush underfoot feeling.

If you like a rockered ride, the Nimbus has a higher toe spring with a more prominent forefoot rocker. This helps to speed up transitions and save you energy. The forefoot of the Nimbus is also stiffer because it’s so thick.

Stability is better in the Glycerin. It has a firmer, more supportive midsole than the Nimbus. It also has a thinner midsole so your feet sit closer to the ground.

On the outsoles, the Glycerin has a lot more rubber coverage than the Nimbus. The Glycerin has a much more durable outsole because almost its entire outsole is protected by rubber.

Upper unit: Glycerin 23 vs Gel Nimbus 28

Brooks Glycerin 23 pair, three-quarter front viewGlycerin 23
Picture of ASICS Gel Nimbus 28Gel Nimbus 28

Both trainers have plush, luxurious feeling uppers but the Nimbus’ knit material is softer and more comfortable than the mesh of the Glycerin. The Nimbus upper feels warmer than the Glycerin and ventilation isn’t as good in the Nimbus.

The tongue of the Nimbus is thin and gusseted while the tongue of the Glycerin is much thicker and has more padding, however, its tongue is not gusseted.

The Nimbus and the Glycerin are true to size but they both have narrow toe boxes. The interior of the Glycerin is a bit more spacious than the Nimbus.

Which one to buy: Glycerin 23 vs Gel Nimbus 28

Medial side of the Brooks Glycerin 23Glycerin 23
Picture of ASICS Gel Nimbus 28Gel Nimbus 28

If you prefer a firmer ride that can handle faster paces better, the Glycerin is the way to go. The Glycerin has better stability and better durability than the Nimbus but it costs $5 more.

If you’re looking for a softer ride for mainly easy and recovery runs, the Nimbus is the better option. The Nimbus has a much plusher ride that feels like a max cushioned trainer. It has a more prominent forefoot rocker and it has a more comfortable upper.

Best price online: Glycerin 23 vs Gel Nimbus 28

Written by Brandon

All articles by Brandon

This comparison was written by Brandon Law. Published . Brandon is a South African marathoner based in Malaysia, where the humidity is high and his shoe rotation is even higher. He’s a runner with a full-blown addiction to running shoes. Most people buy shoes to run—Brandon runs to justify buying more shoes. If there’s a new drop, he’s probably already logged 100km in them.