Editor rating:
8/10 on
BRANDON LAW
User's rating:

PROS

  • Just-right cushioning
  • Excellent versatility
  • Secure lockdown
  • Great value

CONS

  • Heavier than previous version
  • Lumpy forefoot

OUR VERDICT

The ASICS Gel Cumulus 23 continues the Cumulus tradition of being a versatile, neutral daily trainer that you can rely on for hundreds of kilometres.

Version 23 has been updated with a softer mesh and 3D Space Construction zones in the midsole which results in a softer ride.
SHOE INFO
Brand
Gel Cumulus 23
Model
9.9 oz. (281 gr.)
Weight
120 US$
MSRP
10 mm
Heel Drop
Family
Previous model
WHO IS IT FOR
If you're a runner looking for only one shoe in your rotation that can handle every type of run, the Cumulus 23 is your shoe.

The Cumulus 23 has a wallet-friendly price and has no major flaws.

Asics Gel Cumulus 23 Intro

If you were to Google image search “daily training running shoe”, the odds are high that the Asics Cumulus would be one of the first images that pop up.

That’s because the Cumulus is the textbook definition of a comfortable, daily trainer with a versatile ride character. It’s a multipurpose, do-everything shoe which is why it’s been such a crowd pleaser for over two decades.

Recently, ASICS has been pushing the boundaries of innovation and has launched some very exciting shoes.

The problem with exciting shoes is that they’re still new so you never know what you are going to get and if it’s going to work for you.

On the flip side of the coin, you get Asics’ “plain” shoes, their bread and butter trainers that are consistent, dependable and give you what you expect.

Of the three ASICS stalwarts, the Kayano, Nimbus and Cumulus, the Cumulus is the most budget friendly, the lightest and the most versatile.

Compared to other mid-priced, neutral daily trainers from other brands, the Cumulus receives the most updates annually which keeps things exciting and fresh.

While the Nike Pegasus, New Balance 880, Saucony Ride and Hoka Clifton receive upper-only updates every other year, you can expect the Cumulus to get a brand new upper, midsole and outsole every year.

So what’s new on the Cumulus 23?

It now has a softer upper, 3D Space Construction zones in the midsole and a full-length, bottom layer of Flytefoam.

It weighs 280 g (9.9 oz), 16 g (0.6 oz) more than the Cumulus 22 but maintains its 10mm drop and price of $120.

Asics Gel Cumulus 23 First Impressions

Asics Gel Cumulus 23 - Lateral Side

Asics Gel Cumulus 23 – Lateral Side

When I first saw pictures of the Cumulus 23 online, my initial thought was that it looks very similar to the Nimbus 23.

When I held it in hand, the upper mesh felt noticeably better than the previous version: softer and more premium.

Walking around in the Cumulus 23, I could feel that the layer directly underfoot was less spongy than the Nimbus 23 with less of a sink-in sensation.

My first run was a 10km steady-paced run and I was surprised how well it performed when I increased the pace.

Even at tempo speeds of 4.25 minutes per kilometer, the Cumulus 23 didn’t feel like it was out of its comfort zone.

I did notice that I could feel the edges of the outsole lugs through the forefoot and it felt slightly lumpy. This is because of a big difference in density between the midsole foam and the outsole rubber.

After that first impressive 10 kilometer run, I was excited to test the Cumulus 23 on a variety of different runs and paces.

Asics Gel Cumulus 23 Sole Unit

Asics Gel Cumulus 23 - Closeup Lateral

Asics Gel Cumulus 23 – Closeup Lateral

Flytefoam has come a long way. What used to be a really firm, unforgiving foam only suited for fast runs, has now become softer, more lively and more versatile.

The bottom layer of Flytefoam is now a continuous, single-density piece of foam, so ride transitions are smoother. The firmer wedge of Flytefoam has been moved closer to the foot, above the gel pocket.

The Cumulus is supposed to deliver a soft ride- and it does. After all, it is named after a cloud.

The Cumulus 23 is softer than the Ghost 13, Ride 14 and Pegasus 38 but not as soft as the Clifton 7 so it doesn’t feel like you’re sinking down with every foot strike.

The high versatility of the Cumulus 23 means that it can handle easy runs, recovery runs, steady runs and it even has enough cushioning for long distances of 40+ kilometres.

When I tested the Nimbus 23, I felt foot fatigue on longer runs because of how soft and spongy its forefoot is but the Cumulus 23 has just the right amount of cushioning to feel efficient on long runs.

The Cumulus 23 now has 3D Space Construction which are these small hexagonal shapes that look like honeycomb which are etched onto the top layer of the midsole.

The men’s version only has the Space Construction on the heel whereas the women’s version has it on the heel and the forefoot.

These hexagonal shapes in the midsole act like pillars to allow the midsole to compress more in those zones which increases softness.

The Cumulus has always been known as a stable neutral trainer and the Cumulus 23 is no exception. Its midsole is not overly soft so there isn’t much lean bias and foot strikes feel very planted.

Asics Gel Cumulus 23 - Sole

Asics Gel Cumulus 23 – Sole

The flex grooves on the outsole of the Cumulus 23 have been made wider and deeper than the previous version so flexibility in the forefoot has been increased which is a welcome change.

There are two types of rubber used on the outsole of the Cumulus 23: AHAR+ on the heel and AHAR on the forefoot.

The density of the rubber on the Cumulus 23 is higher than that of the Nimbus 23 which leads to firmer landings but increased durability.

There is noticeably less wear on the outsole of the Cumulus 23 than on the outsole of the Nimbus 23 after the same mileage so I’ve been very happy with durability.

I tested the traction during a long run where it poured heavily for 3 hours straight and traction was still fantastic. I never once slipped or felt like I was going to slip.

Asics Gel Cumulus 23 Upper Unit

Asics Gel Cumulus 23 - Top

Asics Gel Cumulus 23 – Top

The upper of the Cumulus 23 is very well-designed with enough padding in all the right places to make it comfortable and effective.

The thick tongue is not gusseted like on the Nimbus 23 but it still stays in place during runs and I experienced no tongue slide.

The collar and heel tab are also generously padded and provide great foot lockdown without even having to do heel lock lacing.

The one downside of the upper is that all the padding absorbs a lot of moisture. When I ran in the rain, both shoes picked up a ton of weight and I felt like I was carrying an extra 1 kilogram of water weight on my feet.

There is also a thin, reflective strip on the heel for nighttime visibility from the rear which is a bonus.

The fit of the Cumulus 23 is true to size and there is plenty of room in the midfoot and forefoot. It should be accommodating enough for most runners without having to get the wide version.

Asics Gel Cumulus 23 Conclusion

Asics Gel Cumulus 23 - Closeup Toe

Asics Gel Cumulus 23 – Closeup Toe

In a world where daily trainers have carbon plates and super foam midsoles, the dependable ASICS Cumulus 23 still doesn’t feel like a boring shoe.

It also doesn’t feel like an exciting shoe. It does however feel well-rounded, well-built, reliable and luxurious.

You don’t have to worry about durability or fit issues with the Cumulus 23, or about getting injured from too much softness or not enough. The Cumulus 23 has the right amount of everything.

The small updates that ASICS has made to the Cumulus 23 have improved it but have made it heavier too, although on foot, it doesn’t feel like a heavy shoe.

I enjoyed the Cumulus 23 most on middle distance runs at easy or steady paces but if I only had one running shoe and it was the Cumulus 23, I’d be very happy with it because it can also handle a variety of different distances and paces.

I would choose the Cumulus over the Nimbus for long runs and for faster runs but I prefer the Nimbus for easy and recovery runs.

The Cumulus 23 may not be as luxurious or as plush as the Nimbus 23 but it’s more versatile, more durable and better value for money.

If you’re an ASICS Cumulus loyalist and you buy it every year, you’ll love the Cumulus 23.

We purchased a pair of Asics Gel Cumulus 23 from runningwarehouse using our own money. This did not influence the outcome of this review, written after running more than 50 miles in them.

Asics Gel Cumulus 23 Price Comparison

This page contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.


Similar shoes to Asics Gel Cumulus 23

Expert score
9/10

Asics Novablast 2 Review

The ASICS Novablast 2 is a unique daily trainer in the ASICS lineup which is ... (Read expert review)
Expert score
10/10

Asics GlideRide 2 Review

I thought Asics did a superb job on these. They are not going to be for ... (Read expert review)
Expert score
7/10

Nike Zoom Pegasus 38 Review

The Nike Air Zoom Pegasus 38 is a very well-built daily trainer which is not ... (Read expert review)
Expert score
10/10

Asics Gel Contend 7 Review

The Asics Gel Contend 7 are a fantastic find for a budget friendly running ... (Read expert review)
Expert score
8/10

Asics EvoRide 2 Review

The ASICS EvoRide 2 is a speedy daily trainer with a distinct forefoot rocker ... (Read expert review)
Expert score
9/10

Asics Gel Nimbus Lite 2 Review

The Nimbus Lite is a great trainer with a versatile fit and smooth enjoyable ... (Read expert review)