Home All running shoes Reviews Racing shoe reviews ... Asics Magic Speed 4 expert review

Asics Magic Speed 4 review

9 expert score
9 user's score
As editorial policy, we do not accept free samples. We purchased this pair at Running Warehouse with our own money.
Review written on 17th August by Jeremy Yoder Jeremy Yoder lives in Marietta, PA with his wife and 2 kids. In an earlier life, he used running to stay fit for his soccer career, where he was a co
21 other reviews

Asics Magic Speed 4 Verdict

The Asics Magic Speed 4 is most easily defined as a budget friendly super shoe. The full length carbon plate will instantly energize your race times or speed training up to the big race.

The pros

  • Budget super shoe
  • Energetic midsole
  • full length carbon plate

The cons

  • downgraded upper material

Rating breakdown

Comfort
9.0
Build quality
8.0
Upper
7.0
Sole unit
9.0
Landing
9.0
Transition
8.0
Toe-off
9.0
Traction
8.0
Durability
8.0
Value / Price
9.0

Facts / Specs

Brand
Model
Magic Speed 4
Previous model
Weight
8.5 oz (241 g)
MSRP
$170.00

Heel
999 mm.
Toe
999 mm.
Heel drop
8 mm.
Carbon plate
Full length carbon plate

Size/Fit

Sizing
True to size
Heel fit
Normal
Midfoot fit
Normal
Toebox fit
Normal

Cushioning & ride

Type of cushioning
Responsive/balanced
Amount of cushioning
Medium cushioning
Stability
Some stability
Flexibility
Rigid

Usage

Racing  
Speedwork  
Daily training
Long distance racing
Ultra distance racing

Who should buy the Asics Magic Speed 4 ?

The Asics Magic Speed 4 is designed to be a tempo training shoe. It will also hold its own in 5k or 10k races and possibly longer. Speed is the name of the game.

Who should not buy the Asics Magic Speed 4 ?

Don’t expect to find a ton of comfort with these on long slow runs. They have lots of cushion but are in no way a daily trainer.

Asics Magic Speed 4 Introduction

Picture of ASICS Magic Speed 4

Like the Magic Speed 3, the latest version offers a full length carbon plate and a layer of FF BLAST PLUS midsole cushioning.

New features in the Magic Speed 4 include a layer of FF TURBO, wider midfoot design and more cushioning throughout the shoe. But with more cushion comes more weight in the form of one additional oz in size 9.

An easy and obvious comparison to the Magic Speed 4 is the Asics Metaspeed series. At $170, the Magic Speed 4 is a more budget friendly, carbon-plated shoe for runners venturing into the super shoe space.

Asics Magic Speed 4 First Impressions

Picture of ASICS Magic Speed 4

Most of my first impressions start with color combos and the Magic Speed 4 were blinding from the moment I cracked the lid of the box.

With a fluorescent yellow upper and orange streaking through the midsole, these act like flashlights on your feet.

In fact, Asics’s website describes them as “safety yellow” which is suitable. I can’t help but think they resemble neon yellow road crew attire that you see driving down the highway. Quite frankly, outside of the unavoidable color, the upper didn’t seem like anything to write home about.

Picture of ASICS Magic Speed 4

When looking over the shoe more, it was impossible to miss the full-bodied FF Turbo midsole. You’ll also get a glimpse of the carbon plate running through the midfoot when you flip them over to check out the ASICSGRIP™ rubber outsole.

My first run in the shoes was a 5 miler and they took some time to get used to. It actually took a few runs until I settled into a comfortable stride. Overall, I was pleased with the initial feel and performance.

Asics Magic Speed 4 Upper

Picture of ASICS Magic Speed 4

Asics made some notable changes to the upper design and material for 2024.

Engineered mesh is the material of choice compared to MOTION WRAP in the Magic Speed 3. This is sort of a head scratcher to me. MOTION WRAP is a more premium material which is used in the METASPEED line. Given the price increase from last year, this almost seems like a downgrade in the upper.

Having said all that, I had no issues with the fit and feel of the upper design. The seamless design was snug and contoured well to my feet for support in all the right places. Breathability was average and what I’d expect from the Engineered mesh.

There would be no issues running in these shoes in extreme heat or cold.

Picture of ASICS Magic Speed 4

A thin, laminated tough wrapped nicely over the top of my foot. Padding on the tongue helped to reduce potential pinch points where the laces make contact. The tongue is also gusseted which helps it stay in place and not slide down or to either side.

Asics beefed up the heel counter with more padding than the previous version. I had no problems with lockdown and was able to gain a secure fit each time I laced up the shoes.

Asics Magic Speed 4 Sole Unit

Picture of ASICS Magic Speed 4

The sole unit starts off with FF Turbo as one of two layers of foam cushioning. The majority of this super bouncy foam sits in the forefoot, assisting in energy return.

Beneath the FF Turbo lies a full length carbon plate which is responsible for propulsion and improving stability. The carbon plate is designed with a late stage rocker, which encourages runners to stay on the balls of their feet and toes.

FF BLAST PLUS makes up the remainder of the midsole and supports the carbon plate. A major benefit of this material is that it’s lightweight. Asics beefed up the stack height overall from last year’s model. An additional 9mms in the heel and 8mms in the toe to be exact.

Last but not least, ASCISGRIP is the rubber that meets the road.

I really enjoyed the ride of the Magic Speed 4. It’s hard to love and have fun in a shoe that promotes speed and long strides.

My primary workouts in this shoe were interval runs, 5k race paces and up to 10 mile tempo runs.

The carbon plate shines when I was running at a pace where my midfoot or forefoot was contacting the ground first. At slower paces when I found my heels striking first, I felt that the shoes became more unpredictable.

Asics Magic Speed 4 Conclusions

This was my first review of a carbon-plated shoe. While I don’t have much to compare them to, it was hard to find any criticisms in the Magic Speed 4.

Offering more cushion and more stability than before. This shoe will help you get the most out of your high paced workouts, whether that’s training for a 5k, marathon or races across those distances.

The Magic Speed 4 is an awesome shoe that I’d highly recommend.

How does the Magic Speed 4 compare?

Asics METASPEED Edge Paris
Asics Magic Speed 4
New Balance FuelCell SuperComp Trainer v2
Expert score
8
9
8
User score
Retail price
US$249.95
US$169.95
US$179.95
Weight
6.5 oz
8.5 oz
9.7 oz
Heel Drop
5 mm
8 mm
6 mm
Recommended for
Racing, speedwork
Racing, speedwork
Speedwork, daily training
Cushioning type
responsive
responsive/balanced
balanced/plush
Cushioning amount
Medium cushioning
Medium cushioning
Highly cushioned
Flexibility
rigid
rigid
medium
Stability
some stability
some stability
very stable
Sizing
buy half size bigger
true to size
true to size

Why you can trust us

As editorial policy, we do not accept free samples from companies.
We purchased this pair of Asics at Running Warehouse  with our own money.

This page contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Read more about our policy.

Reviewed by Jeremy

This review was written by Jeremy Yoder on 17th August.
Jeremy Yoder lives in Marietta, PA with his wife and 2 kids. In an earlier life, he used running to stay fit for his soccer career, where he was a collegiate All American. Jeremy is an avid hunter and now running keeps him prepared for outdoor advendutres. He and his wife Olivia enjoy competing in trail races in the mountains of Pennsylvania. If he could pick, every run would be on a trail run but when life gets busy, the road will do just fine.

User feedback (3)

  • avatar-comment-1052647
    FastFeet85
    1 week ago

    My wallet’s crying looking at super shoe prices lately. These caught my eye as a cheaper option for my upcoming 10K. Not thrilled about the downgraded upper, but man, that price difference compared to Vaporflys is hard to ignore. Might work for my shorter races.

    Your comment is awaiting moderation.
  • avatar-comment-1052139
    Marcus Wellington
    2 weeks ago
    8 score

    After putting 150 miles in the Magic Speed 4, I’m thoroughly impressed with its performance-to-price ratio. Compared to premium super shoes like the Vaporfly or Adios Pro, this delivers 80% of the performance at 60% of the cost. The carbon plate provides noticeable propulsion – I shaved 45 seconds off my 10K PR. The midsole feels energetic without being harsh. My only gripe is the upper material feels a bit cheap compared to the Metaspeed Sky+. Perfect for tempo runs and races up to the half marathon distance. Used them for two recent 10K races and several track workouts. Overall great value for delivering super shoe benefits at a more accessible price point.

    Your comment is awaiting moderation.
  • avatar-comment-1050467
    Lisa K
    1 month ago

    Training for my first half and trying to decide if these could handle both my Tuesday track sessions and race day. Not trying to buy two separate pairs if I can help it! Anyone using these as their do-it-all shoe? Been eyeing the Endorphin Speed 3 too – would love some real-world comparison if anyone’s tried both!

    Your comment is awaiting moderation.
  • avatar-comment-1043072
    Alex R.
    5 months ago

    Would you recommend the Magic Speed 4 for someone transitioning from daily trainers to their first pair of performance shoes? I’m curious if the stiffness might be too much for a beginner at speed work.

  • avatar-comment-1041520
    Lucas P.
    6 months ago
    8 score

    Solid shoe overall! I really liked the balance between responsiveness and cushioning. It feels light but has enough structure to support the foot during longer runs. Toe box could be a bit roomier, but it’s manageable. I also appreciate the breathable upper—no overheating issues even on hot days.

  • avatar-comment-1041238
    Holly P
    6 months ago
    10 score

    I love this shoe! I couldn’t get on with the Magic Speed 3 as they were just too firm for me and tight around the toe box. The Magic Speed 4 is bouncier and perfect around my toes. They also feel so fast, I set my 1k PB in my first run

Lowest price:
$169

Where to buy

Best offers today in United States, all prices in USD

Similar shoes to Asics Magic Speed 4

ASICS S4+ Yogiri Review

The ASICS S4+ Yogiri is a firm marathon racer that feels more like a speed ... (Read expert review)

ASICS Gel Nimbus 27 Review

The Asics Gel-Nimbus 27 is a highly cushioned and stable daily trainer for ... (Read expert review)

ASICS Gel-Contend 9 Review

Gel-Contend 9 is a low-cushion, efficient neutral shoe that's well-made for ... (Read expert review)