Comparison: Nike Metcon 9 vs Nike Metcon 8

Nike's flagship training shoe receives an update. Is it an upgrade? Is the Nike Metcon 9 better than the Metcon 8? We tested both to find out.

Picture of Nike Metcon 9Metcon 9
Picture of Nike Metcon 8Metcon 8

Written by
Founder and Publisher, Running Shoes Guru · 319 articles

Published

We buy every shoe we test with our own money No free samples How we review

The Nike Metcon is an incredibly successful training franchise: go to any gym and you'll find people wearing a pair of Metcon.

Although people seem to wear them as an everyday gym shoe, it is meant for HIIT and Crossfit athletes: their design is very intentional towards some of the activities (for example rope climbing) that are typical of a Crossfit workout and not so much for a normal gym setting.

At $150 is an expensive shoe and so we are wondering... is it worth it to upgrade to the Metcon 9, or should you keep your Metcons 8 for a little longer? (Or try and find a pair on sale?)

Keep reading to find out!

Similarity and differences: Metcon 9 vs Metcon 8

Nike Metcon 9Nike Metcon 9Nike Metcon 8Nike Metcon 8
Expert score6/106/10
User scoreNo ratings yetNo ratings yet
Best price, menNike Metcon 9, men: from $100.00 list price $150.00 33% off as of 15 Nov, 20:12 UTC at Amazon See deal Nike Metcon 8, men: from $90.69 list price $130.00 30% off as of 15 Nov, 20:01 UTC at Amazon See deal
Best price, womenNike Metcon 9, women: No offers right nowNike Metcon 8, women: No offers right now
VerdictThe Nike Metcon 9 is supposed to be a slight step up from the 8 but I believe it fell short and they took the shoe in the wrong direction, but hey maybe thats just me!The Nike Metcon 8 is a wonderful shoe strictly made for crossfit and weight training. This shoe has a solid platform for firm landing, mindless transitioning and a real planted feel to the ground.
ReviewMetcon 9 reviewMetcon 8 review
Brand
Shoe type
Weight12 oz
Heel drop4 mm4 mm
CushioningMedium cushioningMedium cushioning
Cushioning typeBalanced/plushResponsive/balanced
StabilityVery stableVery stable
FlexibilityMediumMedium
Sizingbuy half size smallerbuy half size bigger
Best forHIIT / Crossfit, Weight Lifting / Strength TrainingHIIT / Crossfit, Weight Lifting / Strength Training
Retail priceUS$150US$130

Score breakdown: Metcon 9 vs Metcon 8

Metcon 9Metcon 8
3Comfort10
7Sole unit9
9Upper9
8Transition6
6Toe-off5
9Durability9

Metcon 9 wins: Transition, Toe-off

Metcon 8 wins: Comfort, Sole unit

Even: Upper, Durability

Sole unit: Metcon 9 vs Metcon 8

Sole Comparison Nike Metcon 9 vs Metcon 8

The Metcon 9 comes with a completely redesigned sole unit compared to version 8.

Both shoes feature a blown rubber outsole (for grip in indoor situations) with side panels that wrap around the midfoot to help with rope climbs. Although the geometry is slightly different, the soles have a similar shape.

One big change is in the material: React foam all over for the Metcon 8 and a dual density foam for the Metcon 9. The foam in the Metcon 9 is harder on the inside – for intrinsic stability – and softer on the outside, for comfort.

In reality neither shoe is really meant for running anything longer than a couple of miles, so you won’t find a lot of difference in daily usage.

A common factor in the latest Metcons is the “hyperlift” in the heel: a piece of hard plastic that is supposed to give you more stability and rigidity for hard lifts such as deadlifts and squats – but that will annoy you if you try and run in them. It’s really hard and unforgiving.

The hyperlift in the Metcon 9 is larger than the one in the 8.

Upper unit: Metcon 9 vs Metcon 8

The upper has changed, but in our opinion not for the best.

The fit of the Nike Metcon 9 is wider, especially in the toebox. This is meant to allow your toes to splay and grip the floor more securely while lifting.

In our testing, we found that the wider toebox instead meant our feet didn’t feel as securely locked inside the shoe and kept moving left and right.

Another change we didn’t like was the heel counter: in the 9th version comes up much higher and rubs the ankles.

Which one to buy: Metcon 9 vs Metcon 8

Picture of Nike Metcon 9Metcon 9
Picture of Nike Metcon 8Metcon 8

Overall the two shoes are really similar, although there are quite a few changes for a shoe that at first sight looks virtually unchanged.

We preferred the Nike Metcon 8 to the 9. The upper fit was more comfortable and secure, the hyperlift was a more forgiving size and overall we don’t think the changes introduced made the Metcon a better shoe.

Last words from us: these shoes are both meant with the (competitive) Crossfitter in mind. They are good for weight lifting, but don’t translate well into other activities such as dance classes and running.

Best price online: Metcon 9 vs Metcon 8

Nike Metcon 9 price comparison

Prices for (USD) Prices checked

No offers in United States right now.

We may earn a commission when you buy through these links; it doesn't change your price. How we work

Nike Metcon 8 price comparison

Prices for (USD) Prices checked

No offers in United States right now.

We may earn a commission when you buy through these links; it doesn't change your price. How we work

Written by Ruggero

All articles by Ruggero

This comparison was written by Ruggero Loda. Published . Ruggero is the founder and publisher of Running Shoes Guru. After years of experience working for brands such as Nike, Reebok/Adidas, Ruggero launched Running Shoes Guru in 2009 because he could not find a reliable, independent and trusted source of running shoe reviews elsewhere on the internet.A runner and triathlete, Ruggero has tested dozens of shoes over more than 15 years. He is an advocate for transparency and that's why he purchases all shoes for testing with his own money instead of