Five Fingered Frolic: A review of Vibram FiveFingers Bikila LS Running Shoes

“The foot feels the foot when it feels the ground.”
A fascination with barefoot running began among enthusiasts as far back as 1960, when Adebe Bikila ran a world record-breaking marathon at the Olympics in 2 hours and 15 minutes.  It wasn’t until almost fifty years later that enterprising footwear designers came out with a pair of shoes named after the runner and modeled after his ‘primitive’ strategy for success in endurance running.  Behold, Vibram Five Fingered Bikila’s:

Vibram Five Fingers Bikila

Vibram Five Fingers Bikila

These babies have tricked out individual toe-slots to ramp up dexterity, their quick-lace closure system tightens to a comfortable fit with just one tug, their anti-bacterial treatment and moisture-wicking nylon stops the stink.  However, our recommendation is that you wash them regularly. 

I remember the first time I saw a pair of Vibram Five Finger running shoes I was sitting in an upscale café in Washington DC, and somebody walked in off the street with a pair on his feet.  I thought to myself, “Is it okay for that guy to be in here like that?  He’s not wearing shoes—are those shoes?”  Before long, my roommate, who had debilitating joint problems for years, was sporting a pair and trumpeting their efficiency.  “I feel so much better,” he gushed.  I myself have had some back and knee problems and I wondered whether or not it was time to try these fancy new contraptions out.  Before investing in a pair, I sat down to do my research. 

The man who’s done the most research into this subject is E. Liebermann who has actually built an entire website to display his research.  The first article that I found on Google was a report from Science Daily adapting Harvard Research Materials.  The article gives a good breakdown of the motive behind engineering ‘barefoot’ shoes, and does a good job supporting its assertions with data and theory.  Essentially, the gist of the article is summed up in a quote from E. Liebermann, a professor of human evolutionary biology at Harvard University:

People who don’t wear shoes when they run have an astonishingly different strike. By landing on the middle or front of the foot, barefoot runners have almost no impact collision, much less than most shod runners generate when they heel strike. Most people today think barefoot running is dangerous and hurts, but actually you can run barefoot on the world’s hardest surfaces without the slightest discomfort and pain. All you need is a few calluses to avoid roughing up the skin of the foot. Further [it seems to be] less injurious than the way some people run in shoes.

After describing the scope of the study that they performed to support their thesis, Lieberman’s partner in the study chimed in to say:

Heel-striking is painful when barefoot or in minimal shoes because it causes a large collision force each time a foot lands on the ground… Barefoot runners point their toes more at landing, avoiding this collision by decreasing the effective mass of the foot… Our hope is that an evolutionary medicine approach to running and sports injury can help people run better for longer and feel better while they do it…

So: how does theory play out in real-life?

I bought a pair of Vibram’s Five Fingered Bikila’s for a hundred bucks and decided to put this concept to the test.  As Antonio Porchia said: “Certainties are arrived at only on foot.”  They arrived in the mail on a Monday after I came home from work.  I slipped off the Mephisto Marlans that I wear to the office, and slipped into the Bikilas shoes.  Immediately, just walking around, the sensory shift was dramatic.  Five fingered shoes are (obviously) almost weightless.  Essentially the experience is very similar to walking around in extremely durable tote socks.  I stretched out and went for a run.
Though my usual regimen is at least 4 to 5 miles in the spring, I ran a 1 ½ the first day as per the recommendations of friends.  I’d been directed to run only a mile or two a day until the ligament and musculature in my feet had a chance to develop and correct themselves.  As we can see from studies published in the American Journal of Orthopedic Surgery (the last time that a bare foot lifestyle was common, apparently) the bones of the foot form to fit its container.  In other words, if you’re wearing shoes with high arches, especially when you’re young, your feet will have high arches. 

Just take a look at the photos. 

After a week or two of running on this limited regimen I started dialing up my training.  On week three I ran 4 miles a day.  By week four, I was back up to five miles a day in the Vibram’s—and feeling great!  I’ve been running trails with them for the past few weeks and the experience is completely different on a tactile and experiential level.  It feels—well—primitive, but it also feels just fantastic.  It’s helped with my IT band this past weekend and, by all accounts, I can expect continued benefits if I keep using my Bikila’s as I have been for the past two months.  From posture correction to knee-problems, these shoes are supposed to work out your kinks.  We’ll see what’s changed and what stays the same next autumn. 

In the meantime, I’m a happy customer. 

Thomas Stone is a contributor at Pom Poms and Cigars

{"datafeed":{"items":[{"IS_PREORDER":"0","PREORDER_MSG":"No","MYKEY":"23_047613","DEEP_LINK":"https:\/\/\/go\/index.php?id=23_047613&clickref=&site_id=","MERCHANT_NAME":"Holabird Sports","NAME":"Vibram Bikila Evo: Vibram Fivefingers Women's Running Shoes Black\/yellow\/magenta","MERCHANT_LOGO":"http:\/\/\/logos\/holabird.gif","DISPLAY_PRICE":"69","IN_STOCK":"0","STOCK_MSG":"<i>Out of Stock<\/i>","IMAGE_URL":"http:\/\/\/media\/catalog\/product\/0\/4\/047613_3.jpg","DESCRIPTION":"Vibram Bikila EVO minimalist running shoes deliver efficient forefoot striking by balancing impact and ground feedback.<br\/><br\/>A closed quick-lace system offers a secure, custom fit for enhanced comfort in motion.<br\/><br\/>The separate toe pockets are made to strengthen your toes and improve balance while the innovative design is sure to turn heads.<br\/><br\/>Perfect for runners with high arches.<br\/><br\/>Upper: Polyester mesh offers durable flexibility and breathability.<br\/><br\/>A closed quick-lace system provides a secure, custom fit.<br\/><br\/>3M&trade; reflective surfaces increase visibility for increased safety.<br\/><br\/>Built with tear-resistant TPU toe protection.<br\/><br\/>Midsole: EVA arch follows the contour of the foot and reduces weight.<br\/><br\/>An anti-microbial Dri-Lex&reg; sockliner wicks sweat away from the foot to help keep you feeling dry and comfortable.<br\/><br\/>A polyurethane insole provides maximum comfort and plating for underfoot support.<br\/><br\/>3mm Drilex&trade; covered Polyurethane footbed offers more plating protection and reduced packing over a sustained period of time.<br\/><br\/>Outsole: Vibram&reg; TC-1 Performance rubber delivers excellent foot feel without compromising abrasion resistance.<br\/><br\/>Bikila tread design offers more traction over a variety of surfaces.<br\/><br\/>4mm anatomical pod outsole design distributes forefoot impact forces without compromising important ground feedback essential to a proper forefoot strike running form.<br\/><br\/> Vibram Sizing Chart","IS_CUSTOM":"0","PRODUCT_URL":"display_product.php?mykey=23_047613","PRICE_COMPARE_SQL":"","ORIGINAL_DEEP_LINK":"http:\/\/\/click-3445118-10517952?","DELIVERY_COST":"0.00","PRODUCT_CATEGORY_ID":"14095403","USED_PRICE":"","USERFIELD1":"","USERFIELD2":"","USERFIELD3":"","USERFIELD4":"","MERCHANT_DESCRIPTION":"Free shipping over 69.95$","DATAFEED_ID":"23","COUNTRY_CODE":"USA","RRP_PRICE":"120.00","DELIVERY_TIME":"","CATEGORY":"Sporting Goods > Outdoor Recreation > Running > Running Shoes","SUBCATEGORY":"36","CURRENCY_PREFIX":"$"},{"IS_PREORDER":"0","PREORDER_MSG":"No","MYKEY":"2_vff149","DEEP_LINK":"https:\/\/\/go\/index.php?id=2_vff149&clickref=&site_id=","MERCHANT_NAME":"RoadRunnerSports","NAME":"Womens Vibram Fivefingers Bikila Evo Running Shoe","MERCHANT_LOGO":"http:\/\/\/logos\/rrs_logo.gif","DISPLAY_PRICE":"99","IN_STOCK":"0","STOCK_MSG":"<i>Out of Stock<\/i>","IMAGE_URL":"http:\/\/\/is\/image\/roadrunnersports\/VFF149","DESCRIPTION":"Women&#39;s VIBRAM FIVEFINGERS&reg; BIKILA EVO :: Secure enough support for a medium distance run, while still enjoying all the benefits of a barefoot running shoe with the Women&#39;s Vibram FiveFingers&reg; Bikila EVO.<br\/><br\/>You&#39;ll love the extra protection you&#39;ll get from the light cushioning of the EVA midsole, and you&#39;ll get a strong grip on every turn thanks to the Megagrip rubber pods on the soles.<br\/><br\/>Plus, you&#39;ll be running more miles, breathin&#39; easy and extra comfy in the mesh upper that provides great breathability and a snug, secure fit.","IS_CUSTOM":"0","PRODUCT_URL":"display_product.php?mykey=2_vff149","PRICE_COMPARE_SQL":"","ORIGINAL_DEEP_LINK":"http:\/\/\/click-3445118-12513430?","DELIVERY_COST":"0.00","PRODUCT_CATEGORY_ID":"14096787","USED_PRICE":"","USERFIELD1":"","USERFIELD2":"","USERFIELD3":"","USERFIELD4":"","MERCHANT_DESCRIPTION":"Free shipping, 60-day perfect fit guarantee: possible to exchange shoes after using them for two months.","DATAFEED_ID":"2","COUNTRY_CODE":"USA","RRP_PRICE":"0.00","DELIVERY_TIME":"","CATEGORY":"Footwear,Running,Womens","SUBCATEGORY":"","CURRENCY_PREFIX":"$"}]}}

By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies. more information

The cookie settings on this website are set to "allow cookies" to give you the best browsing experience possible. If you continue to use this website without changing your cookie settings or you click "Accept" below then you are consenting to this.